How to spot a bait-and-switch car shipping quote
The quote that looks best on day one is not always the price you pay on pickup day. A bait-and-switch quote is set low to win your booking, then rises once you’re committed. Here’s how it happens and how to protect yourself.
How car shipping prices are really set
Most car shipments are arranged by brokers. A broker posts your car to a load board where independent carriers choose which loads to take. Carriers pick the loads that pay enough for the miles, the fuel and the time. That means the price that actually moves your car is set by the market on that lane, that week.
A broker can quote you any number they like, but if the price they post is below what carriers will accept, your car simply sits. That’s the moment a low quote turns into a phone call asking for more money.
Warning signs of a bait quote
- It’s far below every other quote you received, not just a little lower.
- It’s far below the estimated range for your route on CompareShipment.
- The broker won’t say whether the price is “all-in” or whether it can change.
- You’re asked for a large non-refundable deposit before a carrier is assigned.
- The pickup date is vague (“we’ll find a driver soon”) but the deposit is due now.
- Pressure to book immediately because the “special price” expires today.
Questions to ask before you book
- Is this price guaranteed, or can it change before a carrier is assigned?
- When do I pay, how much, and is any part of it refundable?
- What happens if no carrier accepts the load at this price?
- Will you tell me the carrier’s name and show me their insurance before pickup?
- What is your FMCSA broker number (MC or USDOT)?
Use a price range as your reference point
The simplest protection is knowing what your route should cost before the calls start. Run your route in our calculator and keep that range in mind. A quote inside the range is realistic. A quote far below it deserves the questions above. A quote far above it gives you room to negotiate.
Prices also move over time. According to SGT Auto Transport’s 2026 report, consumer car shipping prices rose 14.6% in the first half of 2026 compared with the same period a year earlier, largely driven by fuel costs. An old quote or an old price list can be well out of date.
Check the broker’s license
Every legitimate auto transport broker in the US must be registered with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). You can look up any broker by name or number on the FMCSA website and confirm their authority is active. If a company can’t give you a number, move on.
Know your price before the calls start.
Get my price →